Joaquin Phoenix's Napoleon Performance Defended by Film's Historical Advisor Despite Brian Cox's Scathing Critique

Joaquin Phoenix's portrayal of Napoleon Bonaparte in Ridley Scott's 2023 historical epic "Napoleon" has come under fire from actor Brian Cox, who called the performance "truly terrible" and "appalling" during a discussion at the British Library in London. Cox, known for his role in the TV series "Succession," went as far as to say he would have played the role better than Phoenix.

However, the film's historical advisor, Lorris Chevalier, has come to Phoenix's defense. Chevalier acknowledged that while Phoenix wanted to take the character in a different direction, he did the best he could with the material he was given. "Joaquin immersed himself in research, visiting Napoleon's private castle and other Napoleonic sites in Paris," Chevalier said. "He was able to bring Napoleon to life through his acting and Ridley Scott's visuals, even if the film was meant to be more of a visual experience than a documentary."

Cox also criticized the historical accuracy of Mel Gibson's film "Braveheart," in which he had a supporting role. Representatives for Cox and Phoenix did not immediately respond to requests for comment, and a representative for director Ridley Scott declined to comment.

Why this matters: The debate over Phoenix's performance and the film's historical accuracy highlights the ongoing challenges of bringing historical figures to life on the big screen. It also underscores the importance of balancing artistic vision with historical authenticity in biopics and period dramas.

Despite the mixed reviews from critics, with some praising Phoenix's portrayal and others finding it lacking, "Napoleon" has made $221 million worldwide. However, its high budget of $200 million means it is not considered a financial success. The film has received a few Oscar nominations, including for Best Visual Effects, Best Costume Design, and Best Production Design. Clarisse Loughrey from The Independent described Phoenix's performance as "perversely watchable."

The French people have also been critical of the film, with one outlet describing it as "Barbie and Ken under the Empire" and criticizing the actors' American and British accents. Director Ridley Scott responded to the French criticism, saying "The French don't even like themselves" and that the audience he showed the film to in Paris loved it. Ultimately, the mixed reviews and reputation of the film suggest that no one will ever know if Cox would have been a better choice for the role of Napoleon.

Key Takeaways

• Brian Cox criticized Joaquin Phoenix's portrayal of Napoleon as "terrible" and "appalling".
• The film's historical advisor defended Phoenix, saying he did his best with the material.
• Cox also criticized the historical accuracy of Mel Gibson's "Braveheart".
• "Napoleon" has made $221M worldwide but is not considered a financial success.
• The French have been critical of the film, with one outlet describing it as "Barbie and Ken".