Andhra Pradesh High Court Rules Math and Science Textbooks Not Protected by Copyright

The Andhra Pradesh High Court rules that math and science textbooks are not subject to copyright, allowing private schools more flexibility in curriculum development and teaching materials.

author-image
Dil Bar Irshad
Updated On
New Update
Andhra Pradesh High Court Rules Math and Science Textbooks Not Protected by Copyright

Andhra Pradesh High Court Rules Math and Science Textbooks Not Protected by Copyright

The Andhra Pradesh High Court has ruled that textbooks on mathematics and science do not fall under copyright law, quashing a 2010 government order that had restricted private schools from publishing their own books. The court also dismissed a criminal case against a Guntur-based publishing house, Deepthi Publications, which publishes math and science books for school students and engineering entrance exams.

In its ruling, the court held that the publisher's actions fell under the fair use doctrine, and that textbooks do not qualify as original literary works under the Copyright Act of 1957. The court said the books are for the benefit of students and institutions, and are therefore protected under the fair use exceptions for educational uses.

The court's decision overturns the previous restrictions and allows private schools to publish their own textbooks on math and science subjects, providing them more flexibility in curriculum development and teaching materials. The ruling is in line with previous court judgments that have excluded educational materials from copyright protection, as long as they are not verbatim reproductions but involve selection, coordination, or arrangement of pre-existing data.

Why this matters: The Andhra Pradesh High Court's ruling has significant implications for education in the state, as it allows private schools and publishers more freedom in developing and distributing textbooks for key subjects like mathematics and science. This could lead to a greater variety of learning materials and teaching approaches, potentially benefiting students.

The ruling comes amid a warning from the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) against infringement of its educational materials by unscrupulous publishers. However, the Andhra Pradesh High Court's decision clarifies that textbooks dealing with mathematical equations and science subjects do not fall under copyright law due to their non-literary nature and the fair use exception for educational purposes.

Key Takeaways

  • AP HC rules math/science textbooks not covered by copyright law
  • Dismisses case against publisher for publishing own math/science books
  • Allows private schools to publish their own math/science textbooks
  • Ruling aligns with previous court judgments on educational materials
  • Significant for education in AP, allowing more textbook variety