Study Reveals Mixed Results on Long-Term Effectiveness of Preschool Programs

A new study analyzing publicly funded preschool programs finds mixed evidence on their long-term effectiveness in promoting academic success. The study's results challenge the assumption that preschool programs are universally effective, highlighting the need for more research into effective preschool practices.

author-image
Aqsa Younas Rana
Updated On
New Update
Study RevealsMixed Resultson Long-Term Effectiveness of Preschool Programs

Long-Term Effectiveness of Preschool Programs

A new study published in the journal Science today finds mixed evidence on the long-term effectiveness of preschool programs in promoting academic success. The groundbreaking research, conducted by a team from Teachers College, Columbia University, University of Virginia, University of California-Irvine, and University of Delaware, analyzed published evaluations of established, publicly funded preschool programs that used rigorous designs.

Why this matters: The findings of this study have significant implications for education policy and funding, as they challenge the assumption that preschool programs are universally effective in promoting academic success. The findings of this study have significant implications for education policy and funding, as they challenge the assumption that preschool programs are universally effective in promoting academic success. The results also highlight the need for more research into effective preschool practices, which could have a lasting impact on the educational outcomes of disadvantaged children.

The results show a mix of positive, negative, and neutral outcomes in the academic performance of preschool attendees compared to non-attendees. Two evaluations of scaled-up programs had contrasting findings: Boston's public preschool program improved high school graduation rates, while Tennessee's Voluntary Pre-K program led to poorer grades in elementary school. Two other evaluations found no difference between the two groups.

"Preschool programs have long been hailed as effective interventions, but our study reveals a more nuanced reality," said Margaret Burchinal, research professor at the University of Virginia's Center for Advanced Study of Teaching and Learning and the study's senior author. The findings challenge common assumptions in the field and highlight the need to identify key factors that promote skills critical for academic and life success, particularly for disadvantaged children.

Burchinal emphasized the importance of reliable childcare for workforce participation, especially for parents with limited financial resources. Critically, for parents, especially those with limited financial resources, access to reliable child care is vital to workforce participation. Equally important are public preschool programs that not only provide reliable care, but also lay a solid foundation for their children's academic success," she added.

Tyler Watts, assistant professor of developmental psychology at Teachers College, Columbia University, cautioned against making policy recommendations based on the effects of public pre-K programs. "Our research suggests that researchers should be more cautious when making policy recommendations regarding the effects of public pre-K programs," he said.

The study calls for more research into effective preschool practices and warns against basing policy decisions on limited evidence. The authors argue that optimistic findings from older studies may not apply to current programs, and researchers should be more cautious about claiming long-term effects of public pre-K.

While clinical trials from over 50 years ago found solid benefits for preschool programs, recent studies show mixed results. Today's programs and childcare options may differ significantly from earlier ones. Parents now have access to various safety-net services and childcare choices that could impact a child's development as much as or more than a preschool program.

The researchers urge more studies to track the success of preschool attendees and non-attendees and to identify the "active ingredients" that set successful programs apart. They stress that preschool programs should be designed to consistently promote school success, especially for low-income children. Reliable childcare is essential for workforce participation, and public preschools should provide dependable care while building a strong foundation for children's academic success.

The study, funded by the National Institutes of Health, is the first of its kind to systematically review the evidence on the long-term effects of large-scale public preschool programs. It highlights the need for continued research and careful consideration when making policy decisions that impact the lives of young children and their families.

Key Takeaways

  • New study finds mixed evidence on long-term effectiveness of preschool programs.
  • Results show positive, negative, and neutral outcomes in academic performance.
  • Study challenges assumption that preschool programs are universally effective.
  • More research needed to identify effective preschool practices and "active ingredients".
  • Reliable childcare essential for workforce participation and academic success.