Survey Reveals Significant Price Differences Between Major Australian Supermarkets

Aussie shoppers save big at Aldi over Coles and Woolies, with pricing disparities and misleading promotions uncovered in surveys. Coles outperforms Woolies in sales, prompting price cuts to catch up.

Geeta Pillai
Updated On
New Update
Survey Reveals Significant Price Differences Between Major Australian Supermarkets

Survey Reveals Significant Price Differences Between Major Australian Supermarkets

A recent survey of over 1,000 Australian consumers has uncovered notable pricing disparities among the country's leading supermarket chains - Woolworths, Coles, and Aldi. The findings suggest that shoppers can potentially save a substantial amount on their grocery bills by opting to purchase from Aldi compared to its competitors.

One consumer, Lidia, shared her personal experience, highlighting the sharp contrast in prices. Her grocery haul from Aldi, consisting of more than 35 items, amounted to $255. However, a smaller shop at Coles for additional items set her back $78. Expressing her frustration, Lidia referred to the pricing practices at Coles and Woolworths as "price gouging," encouraging fellow shoppers to prioritize Aldi for their grocery needs to save money.

Lidia's video, detailing her shopping experience, has gone viral on social media, resonating with numerous consumers who have encountered similar situations. Many have praised Aldi for its commitment to providing affordable prices without compromising on product quality. However, a few customers have reported that Aldi's prices are not always significantly lower than those of its rivals.

The consumer group CHOICE conducted a comprehensive survey involving over 1,000 Australian shoppers to compare the pricing strategies and promotional practices employed by Woolworths, Coles, and Aldi. The survey revealed that one in four participants struggled to determine whether the in-store price labels represented genuine discounts or not. Coles' "while stocks last" tag and Aldi's "super savers" label were identified as particularly misleading, with less than half of the respondents able to easily ascertain if they were authentic price reductions.

Woolworths also faced criticism for its use of "prices dropped" labels on products that had previously been discounted. CHOICE has called for the implementation of stricter regulations governing the display of prices to prevent consumers from feeling "tricked" by supermarkets. In response, the supermarket chains have stated their commitment to providing clear and transparent pricing information to their customers.

A separate survey conducted by JPMorgan, also involving over 1,000 Australian consumers, shed light on the evolving market dynamics among the major supermarket chains. The findings indicated that Coles is currently outperforming Woolworths in terms of sales and market share growth. In the first two months of 2024, Coles recorded a 4.9% increase in sales, while Woolworths experienced a more modest 1.5% growth.

To bridge the gap, Woolworths has taken steps to reduce its price premium compared to Aldi by approximately 160 basis points, bringing it down to 7.8% in April from 9.4% in March. Coles, on the other hand, maintained a relatively stable premium of 7.7% in April, a slight decrease from 7.9% in March. The price reductions were observed across various product categories, including lamb, sausages, deli items, chicken, beef, pork, cheese, and baked goods.

Why this matters: The pricing disparities and promotional practices of major supermarket chains have a significant impact on Australian consumers' grocery expenses, especially during the current cost-of-living crisis. The findings of these surveys highlight the need for increased transparency and clearer pricing regulations to ensure that shoppers can make informed decisions and get the best value for their money.

Analysts suggest that Woolwor

Key Takeaways

  • Aldi offers significantly lower prices than Woolworths and Coles for grocery items.
  • Consumers struggle to determine if in-store price labels represent genuine discounts.
  • Coles outperformed Woolworths in sales and market share growth in early 2024.
  • Woolworths reduced its price premium compared to Aldi by 160 basis points.
  • Pricing transparency and regulations are needed to help consumers get the best value.