DNA Evidence Leads to Arrest in 2010 Indiana County Gas Station Robbery

Alexander Pelletier, 32, was arrested on April 30, 2024, in connection with a 2010 robbery at a Pennsylvania convenience store. DNA evidence found on a bandana left at the scene led to his arrest nearly 14 years after the incident.

author-image
Mazhar Abbas
New Update
DNA Evidence Leads to Arrest in 2010 Indiana County Gas Station Robbery

DNA Evidence Leads to Arrest in 2010 Indiana County Gas Station Robbery

Alexander Theodule Pelletier, 32, of Williamsport, Pennsylvania, was arrested on April 30, 2024, in connection with a 2010 robbery at the Shelocta BP convenience store in Armstrong Township, Indiana County. The arrest comes nearly 14 years after the incident, thanks to DNA evidence found on a bandana left at the scene.

Why this matters: The successful resolution of this cold case highlights the power of DNA evidence in solving crimes and brings hope to victims and families of unsolved crimes. As DNA analysis techniques continue to improve, the chances of solving cold cases increase, serving as a deterrent to criminals who may believe they have escaped justice.

The robbery occurred on September 17, 2010, when a suspect wearing a bandana over his face and a hooded sweatshirt entered the Shelocta BP convenience store along State Route 422. The suspect allegedly held up his hand, covered in a bandana, and demanded money from an employee. When the suspect threatened to shoot the employee, a fight ensued, with the employee swinging a vacuum at the assailant. Pelletier hit the employee at least once before fleeing the scene.

The case remained unsolved for over a decade until a breakthrough in March 2024, when the Pennsylvania State Police Laboratory Services notified authorities that Pelletier's DNA was found on the bandana left at the crime scene. This vital piece of evidence led to Pelletier being interviewed and then arrested.

Pelletier now faces charges of robbery, a felony count, and misdemeanor counts of simple assault and criminal attempted theft by unlawful taking or disposition. His preliminary hearing is scheduled for May 14, 2024, where he will face the charges stemming from the 2010 incident.

The successful resolution of this case highlights the importance of preserving evidence and the tireless efforts of law enforcement professionals who continue to pursue leads and explore new avenues, even when a case may seem to have gone cold. "DNA evidence found on the bandana covering the suspect's face was matched to Pelletier on March 7, 2024, leading to his arrest on April 30, 2024," according to the case summary.

As DNA analysis techniques become more sophisticated and databases of DNA profiles continue to grow, the chances of solving cold cases like the 2010 Shelocta BP robbery increase significantly. This development not only brings closure to victims and their families but also serves as a powerful deterrent to criminals who may believe they have escaped justice.

The upcoming legal proceedings will determine the outcome of this 14-year-old case, but the arrest itself marks a significant victory for law enforcement and a demonstration of the enduring hope that cold cases can one day be solved. Pelletier's preliminary hearing, scheduled for May 14, 2024, will be the next step in bringing justice to the victim of thislong-unsolved crime.

Key Takeaways

  • Alexander Pelletier, 32, arrested for 2010 robbery in Indiana County, PA.
  • DNA evidence from bandana left at scene linked to Pelletier 14 years later.
  • Pelletier faces charges of robbery, assault, and attempted theft.
  • Case highlights power of DNA evidence in solving cold cases.
  • Preliminary hearing scheduled for May 14, 2024.