Miami Appeals Ruling on Racially Gerrymandered Districts

Miami appeals a federal judge's ruling that its voting districts were unconstitutionally drawn based on race. The city risks escalating legal costs and must create a new map free of racial biases to reshape voter representation.

author-image
Aqsa Younas Rana
New Update
Miami Appeals Ruling on Racially Gerrymandered Districts

Miami Appeals Ruling on Racially Gerrymandered Districts

The city of Miami is appealing a federal judge's ruling that found its voting districts were unconstitutionally drawn based on race, a move that could prolong a contentious legal battle and result in a potential $1.6 million payout for plaintiffs' legal fees. The appeal comes after U.S. District Court Judge K. Michael Moore invalidated the boundaries of the city's five districts last month, citing public remarks made by city commissioners in 2022 that the voting map was designed to ensure racial diversity on the commission.

Why this matters: The outcome of this case has significant implications for voting rights and representation in Miami, and potentially sets a precedent for other cities grappling withgerrymandered districts. Fair redistricting practices are crucial for ensuring that all communities have an equal voice in local government, and a ruling in favor of the plaintiffs could lead to more inclusive and representative city commissions across the country.

The case was brought against Miami in 2022 by voting rights activists represented by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), who alleged that the city's redistricting plan violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. Last week, the City Commission seemed poised to approve a settlement that included a new voting map with minor changes and the nearly $1.6 million payment to cover the plaintiffs' legal costs. However, Commissioners Joe Carollo and Manolo Reyes expressed concerns over the proposed map, emphasizing the importance of ensuring diversity on the commission.

Commissioner Miguel Gabela accused the current map of being designed to divide Coconut Grove to "accommodate" Commissioner Carollo's house and protect former Commissioner Alex Díaz de la Portilla. "This is how we got into this problem," Gabela stated. The proposed settlement agreement with the NAACP and ACLU includes placing Coconut Grove entirely in District 2 and Overtown in District 5, as well as a ballot question and a redistricting committee.

Gabela delayed a vote on the agreement, citing the absence of newly elected District 2 Commissioner Damián Pardo. He expects Pardo and Commissioner Christine King to support the settlement, while anticipating opposition from Commissioners Reyes and Carollo. "The people of Miami deserve fair redistricting maps that are not racially discriminatory. That is what this case has been about from day one," said Howard Simon, Florida ACLU Interim Executive Director. "We are hopeful commissioners will approve the agreement next Thursday and end this lengthy court battle."

If the settlement is not approved, the city risks escalating legal costs. Gabela warned, "If we don't vote in favor of this map, we're not going to have control." The ACLU has praised Judge Moore's ruling as a "huge win for Miami, for representation." The city must now create a new map free of racial biases that will reshape the political landscape and voter representation in Miami. Potential remedies being considered include holding special elections under the new district boundaries.

Key Takeaways

  • Miami appeals federal judge's ruling that its voting districts were unconstitutionally drawn based on race.
  • The case has significant implications for voting rights and representation in Miami and beyond.
  • The ACLU alleges Miami's redistricting plan violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.
  • A proposed settlement includes a new voting map and a $1.6 million payment to cover plaintiffs' legal costs.
  • If the settlement is not approved, the city risks escalating legal costs and loss of control over the redistricting process.