Scottish Parliament Considers Electing Committee Conveners to Boost Government Accountability

The Scottish Parliament is considering electing committee conveners instead of having them appointed by party leaders, aiming to enhance parliamentary scrutiny of the government and rebalance the power dynamic.

author-image
Hadeel Hashem
New Update
Scottish Parliament Considers Electing Committee Conveners to Boost Government Accountability

Scottish Parliament Considers Electing Committee Conveners to Boost Government Accountability

The Scottish Parliament's standards committee is examining a possible adjustment to how committee conveners are chosen, with the aim of enhancing the parliament's capacity to hold the Scottish Government accountable. Being considered is a system where conveners would be elected by MSPs, rather than appointed by party leaders as is currently done.

The committee is requesting input from all 129 MSPs as well as key decision-making bodies on the suggested change. Advocates assert that having elected conveners would promote more independent-minded scrutiny of government policies and actions by committee members.

Currently, apprehensions have been expressed that some MSPs, particularly those belonging to the governing party, may be reluctant to vehemently criticize policies put forth by their own government when the committee conveners are appointed by party leadership. The suggested elected convener system is based on the model used in the UK Parliament, which has resulted in backbench MPs being more outspoken and independent in their committee roles.

Supporters think that enabling MSPs to select their own conveners would offer an alternative path for them to influence policy without the necessity of becoming government ministers. This could help rebalance the power dynamic between the parliament and the government, encouraging more MSPs to think and act independently in their committee oversight responsibilities.

Why this matters: The suggested reforms to the Scottish Parliament's committee system could considerably impact how the Scottish Government is held to account. Having more independent-minded and outspoken committee conveners and members may result in stronger challenges to government policies and decisions.

As the standards committee gathers feedback from MSPs and other stakeholders, it will carefully consider the potential benefits of electing conveners against the current system of appointment by party leaders. Any changes would signify a notable shift in how the Scottish Parliament operates and could alter the dynamics between the legislative and executive branches in Scotland.

Key Takeaways

  • Scottish Parliament examining electing committee conveners, not party appointment
  • Aims to enhance Parliament's ability to hold Scottish Government accountable
  • Elected conveners may promote more independent scrutiny of government policies
  • Elected convener model based on UK Parliament, empowering backbench MPs
  • Changes could shift power dynamics between legislative and executive branches