Summer Lee Faces Primary Challenge Over Israel Criticism

Summer Lee, a progressive Democratic congresswoman, faces a primary challenge from Edgewood Councilmember Bhavini Patel over her criticism of Israel's policies, highlighting the divide within the Democratic Party on the Israel-Palestine issue.

author-image
Shivani Chauhan
Updated On
New Update
Summer Lee Faces Primary Challenge Over Israel Criticism

Summer Lee Faces Primary Challenge Over Israel Criticism

Summer Lee, a progressive Democratic congresswoman from Western Pennsylvania, is confronting a primary challenge from Edgewood Councilmember Bhavini Patel in her 2024 reelection bid. Lee, who ousted a well-known incumbent to win her seat in 2022, is considered the favorite in the primary. However, the race has drawn attention due to Lee's criticism of Israel's policies, which has angered some Jewish constituents but gained her support from progressive groups.

The defining issue between the two candidates appears to be their views on the Israel-Hamas war, with Patel criticizing Lee for being too sympathetic to the Palestinians and not being there for the Jewish community. Lee's votes against pro-Israel resolutions have led to criticism from many Jewish voters. "Summer Lee, a freshman Democratic congresswoman from Western Pennsylvania, is confronting a primary challenge from Edgewood Councilmember Bhavini Patel in her first House reelection bid," one summary states.

Despite the controversy, Lee has the support of prominent Democrats, including Senators Bob Casey and John Fetterman, as well as local leaders. She also has the backing of progressive figures like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who joined a rally for Lee in Pittsburgh, urging the crowd to send a message to the country and the '1 percent' that their funds are not welcome.

Why this matters: The race highlights the growing divide within the Democratic Party over Israel-Palestine relations and the influence of pro-Israel groups in elections. The outcome could indicate the direction the party is heading on this contentious foreign policy issue.

While pro-Israel groups like AIPAC and Democratic Majority for Israel spent heavily against Lee in 2022, they have largely sat out this race, citing concerns about Patel's low profile and Lee's strong polling. Lee has been forced to make some compromises with the pro-Israel community, but her support for most of Biden's domestic agenda and willingness to work across party lines have also played a role in the groups' decision. Despite the absence of major pro-Israel groups, Patel has raised a decent amount of money, though Lee has significantly outraised her.

The issue of Israel-Palestine relations has particular resonance in the Pittsburgh area, which was the site of the deadliest antisemitic attack in U.S. history in 2018. Lee has defended her work in the community following a recent Hamas attack, saying she was present and not just campaigning. "The issue has particular resonance in the Pittsburgh area, home to a large Jewish community and the site of the deadliest antisemitic attack in U.S. history," according to one summary. As the primary approaches, both candidates are receiving significant air cover from outside groups, with Lee's support coming from progressive organizations.

Key Takeaways

  • Summer Lee, a progressive Democrat, faces primary challenge from Bhavini Patel.
  • Dispute centers on Lee's criticism of Israel's policies, angering some Jewish voters.
  • Lee has support from prominent Democrats but faces opposition from pro-Israel groups.
  • Race highlights divide in Democratic Party over Israel-Palestine relations.
  • Outcome could indicate direction of Democratic Party on this foreign policy issue.