MLB 2024: Reasons for Optimism and Pessimism After Five Weeks

The 2024 MLB season enters its sixth week, with teams like the Atlanta Braves, Philadelphia Phillies, and Baltimore Orioles showing promise, while others struggle with injuries and inconsistent performance. The NL Central division remains closely contested, with the St. Louis Cardinals and Chicago Cubs vying for the lead.

Salman Khan
Updated On
New Update
MLB 2024: Reasons for Optimism and Pessimism After Five Weeks

MLB 2024: Reasons for Optimism and Pessimism After Five Weeks

The 2024 MLB season enters its sixth week, teams across the league are taking stock of their performance thus far. While some clubs have reasons to be optimistic about their prospects, others are struggling with concerns that could hinder their success. The Atlanta Braves boast the best lineup in baseball, with athleticism, power, and speed. They have a plus defender at every position and the depth to withstand injuries. However, the loss of ace Spencer Strider to season-ending elbow surgery is a significant blow to their chances of defending their NL East title and winning another World Series.

The Philadelphia Phillies have three starting pitchers (Zack Wheeler, Ranger Suárez, and Spencer Turnbull) with ERAs under 2.00, and their rotation leads the majors in strikeouts and batting average against. Despite this, several key players, including Nick Castellanos, Bryson Stott, Kyle Schwarber, and Bryce Harper, are struggling at the plate, which could hinder their chances of finishing ahead of the Braves. The Phillies re-signed Aaron Nola to a lucrative seven-season deal this winter, but he had a down year in 2023, posting a 4.46 ERA. While Nola has pitched exceptionally well in his last five starts, reducing his ERA to 3.20, Matt Gelb of The Athletic notes, "Nola is throwing more sinkers than he has in years. He has yet to allow an extra-base hit on a sinker. He has often commanded it better than the four-seam fastball. Now, Nola has almost identical usage with his four-seamer and sinker. Maybe that's a path forward for him." fans, buy, stock, star, right

The New York Mets are benefiting from Carlos Mendoza's strong performance as a rookie manager and better-than-expected starting pitching, led by Luis Severino (2.31 ERA) and José Buttó (2.57 ERA). However, the Mets are middle of the pack in most offensive categories and have lost catcher Francisco Alvarez for significant time because of injury. They may need to ponder dealing first baseman Pete Alonso at the trade deadline if they're out of contention. The Mets have a 15-15 record, which is considered decent given their low expectations heading into the season and the injury to ace Kodai Senga. However, a .500 record won't be enough to secure a postseason berth, and the team needs to improve over the next 132 games.

The Washington Nationals have seen CJ Abrams become one of the most exciting offensive players in baseball, while Jesse Winker looks like a Comeback Player of the Year candidate. Left-handed starters MacKenzie Gore (3.19 ERA) and Mitchell Parker (2.53 ERA) are primed for breakout campaigns. On the downside, Patrick Corbin is once again one of the worst starting pitchers in baseball, and Josiah Gray, a 2023 All-Star, is on the IL with an elbow injury. Nationals outfielder James Wood is batting .323/.427/.475 at Triple-A and is becoming a popular stash candidate in redraft leagues, with a potential call-up in June.

The Miami Marlins have one of the best young managers in the game in Skip Schumaker and are improving their technology and analytics departments in the front office. Bryan De La Cruz and Jazz Chisholm Jr. are healthy and have the potential to live up to high expectations. However, while the Marlins have a postseason-caliber rotation, most of their starters are on the IL, including Sandy Alcantara and Eury Pérez, who are out for the year after Tommy John surgeries.

The NL Central division is closely contested, with all five teams within five games of each other. The Milwaukee Brewers have one of the top five offenses in the NL, thanks to reasons, optimistic by catcher William Contreras (.345 BA, .420 OBP, .538 SLG) and second baseman Brice Turang (.309 BA, .370 OBP, 14 stolen bases in 14 attempts). Matt Gelb of The Athletic notes, "William Contreras is having a breakout season, slashing .348/.426/.545 with a 173 wRC. The team's offense has been prolific, with five healthy players having a wRC of 120 or above in April." However, the Brewers' pitching staff needs to find consistency.

The Seattle Mariners' dominant pitching staff has been a bright spot, showcasing why many experts considered it one of the best in baseball entering the season. Former MLB veteran Mike Blowers noted the team needs to improve its offense, saying, "The Mariners' pitching staff has been outstanding, but they need more production from their lineup." Despite boasting one of the league's top rotations, the Mariners rank in the bottom third in runs scored, batting average, and on-base percentage.

The Baltimore Orioles have been one of the biggest surprises in baseball, leading the AL East with a 20-10 record. Their stats, week, ending, may 2nd were impressive, with a team batting average of .289, an OPS of .823, and a 3.14 ERA from their starters. However, the Orioles' success may not be sustainable, as they have benefited from a favorable early schedule and have yet to face many of the league's top teams.

The New York Yankees have struggled out of the gate, with a 14-16 record and several key players underperforming. Despite boasting one of the most talented rosters in baseball, the Yankees have been plagued by injuries and inconsistent pitching. They will need to turn things around quickly to avoid falling too far behind in the competitive AL East race.

In the NL Central, the St. Louis Cardinals and Chicago Cubs are locked in a tight battle for the division lead. The Cardinals have been led by their potent offense, which ranks near the top of the league in most offensive categories. However, their pitching staff has been inconsistent, and they will need to shore up their rotation if they hope to make a deep postseason run. The Cubs, meanwhile, have been buoyed by their strong starting pitching, but their offense has been inconsistent. Both teams will need to address their weaknesses if they hope to separate themselves from the pack in thereview, central.

Overall, the 2024 MLB season has been full of surprises and compelling storylines. While some teams have exceeded expectations, others have struggled to find their footing. The season progresses, it will be interesting to see which teams can sustain their early success and which ones can turn things around and make a push for the postseason.

Key Takeaways

  • Braves boast best lineup in baseball, but loss of Spencer Strider hurts title chances.
  • Phillies' strong rotation led by Zack Wheeler, but key players struggle at plate.
  • Mets' rookie manager Carlos Mendoza impresses, but team needs offense to contend.
  • Orioles surprise with 20-10 record, but success may not be sustainable.
  • NL Central division is closely contested, with Cardinals and Cubs vying for lead.