Giants Considering Drafting QB J.J. McCarthy or WR Jaxon Nabers with No. 6 Pick

The Giants face a crucial decision at #6 in the 2024 NFL Draft, weighing options like QB J.J. McCarthy or WR Jaxon Nabers. Schoen must balance risks and rewards as he looks to accelerate the team's rebuild.

author-image
Salman Khan
Updated On
New Update
Giants Considering Drafting QB J.J. McCarthy or WR Jaxon Nabers with No. 6 Pick

Giants Considering Drafting QB J.J. McCarthy or WR Jaxon Nabers with No. 6 Pick

The New York Giants are considering their options with the 6th overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, with the latest mock drafts suggesting they are contemplating selecting either quarterback J.J. McCarthy from Michigan or wide receiver Jaxon Nabers from Florida State.

The Giants have a pressing need at both positions as they look to strengthen their roster and enhance their chances of success in the upcoming season.

Giants general manager Joe Schoen has kept the team's draft plans close to the vest, leaving open the possibility of trading up, trading down, or staying put at No. 6 to draft a quarterback or receiver. However, there are indications that top quarterback prospects like Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, and Drake Maye could all be off the board by the time the Giants are on the clock, potentially forcing Schoen to trade up if he has his heart set on one of them.

While the Giants are reportedly "comfortable" with their current quarterback group, Schoen may revisit the position in the 2025 draft if he isn't enamored with the remaining options this year. The Minnesota Vikings and Denver Broncos are also seen as potential threats to trade up for a quarterback, adding another variable for the Giants to consider.

If the Giants stay at No. 6, McCarthy and Nabers are two intriguing prospects who could make an immediate impact. McCarthy is coming off a National Championship win at Michigan and is described as a "blue-collar quarterback with tons of intangibles" who possesses good leadership qualities, toughness, and decision-making. However, some analysts question whether he has the elite physical tools to become a franchise quarterback at the next level.

Nabers, on the other hand, is a dynamic playmaker who could provide a much-needed explosive element to the Giants' receiving corps. He has the size, speed, and athleticism to be a game-changer at the NFL level and could be an ideal target for quarterback Daniel Jones.

Why this matters: The Giants' decision with the No. 6 pick will have significant ramifications for the franchise's future. Selecting the right quarterback or receiver could accelerate their rebuilding process and put them on the path to contention, while a misstep could set them back for years to come.

The Giants will have to consider the potential rewards and risks of each option as they navigate the draft. As one NFC executive put it, "The Giants are in a tough spot at No. 6. They may have to get aggressive and trade up for their guy, but that's a big swing to take. Staying put and taking the best player available might be the safer play, but it might not move the needle as much. It's a critical decision for Schoen and the organization."

Key Takeaways

  • Giants considering QB J.J. McCarthy or WR Jaxon Nabers with 6th pick in 2024 NFL Draft.
  • Top QB prospects like Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels may be off the board, forcing Giants to trade up.
  • Giants "comfortable" with current QB group, may revisit position in 2025 draft if options lacking.
  • McCarthy and Nabers are intriguing prospects who could make immediate impact for Giants.
  • Giants' 6th pick decision critical for franchise's future, with risks and rewards to consider.