Vikings Trade Up for Dallas Turner in 2024 NFL Draft, Sparking Debate

The Minnesota Vikings traded up to select defensive player Dallas Turner with the 17th overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. The team gave up significant draft capital, including two 2nd-round picks, to acquire Turner, considered a top-tier talent.

author-image
Bijay Laxmi
New Update
Vikings Trade Up for Dallas Turner in 2024 NFL Draft, Sparking Debate

Vikings Trade Up for Dallas Turner in 2024 NFL Draft, Sparking Debate

The Minnesota Vikings made a bold move in the 2024 NFL Draft, trading up to select defensive player Dallas Turner with the 17th overall pick. Turner, considered one of the top defenders in the draft, was acquired by the Vikings in a trade with the Jacksonville Jaguars that involved giving up two 2nd-round picks, the 23rd overall pick, a 5th-round pick, and next year's 3rd and 4th-round picks.

The Vikings' trade to acquire Turner has sparked debate among fans and analysts, with some questioning the amount of draft capital spent to select an edge rusher in the middle of the first round. Josh Frey and KJoudry, contributors to The Skol Debate, present opposing views on the trade. Frey believes the cost is worth it, considering the quality of player the Vikings landed, while Joudry defends the overpay position.

Frey states, "If we're simply applying the term overpay to draft trade charts... then yes, the Vikings did overpay by just about every metric." Joudry counters, "I think we can argue that Minnesota overpaid... The topic is one that you've covered in your writing for PurplePTSD."

The Vikings initially traded up to select quarterback J.J. McCarthy with the 10th overall pick before orchestrating the trade with the Jaguars to land Turner. Vikings' general manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah saw Turner as a top-tier talent at the second-most important position in football and was willing to pay the price to secure him.

Dallas Turner was widely considered a top 10 lock in the draft, with a consensus ranking of 9th overall and the top-ranked defender by many draft analysts. The New York Jets' draft room footage revealed that they expected the Atlanta Falcons to take Turner with the 8th overall pick, making him the first defender off the board. However, the Falcons surprised many by selecting quarterback Michael Penix Jr. instead, prompting the Vikings to trade up to ensure they got their man.

An anonymous source commented on the Vikings' move, stating,"The fact that Kwesi [Adofo-Mensah] paid extra to get him at 17 is irrelevant. Teams saw the dude as a top 10 lock. "Turner received 9 first-place votes in a poll of 16 NFL personnel staffers by GoLongTD's Bob McGinn, solidifying his status as the top defensive player in the draft.

While the Vikings gave up significant draft capital to acquire Turner, they believe they have landed a game-changing defensive player who can make an immediate impact. The debate surrounding the trade is likely to continue, but the Vikings are confident they made the right move to bolster their defense with a top talent like Dallas Turner.