70 Jewish CUPE Members File Human Rights Complaint Against Union Over Hamas Support

Seventy Jewish CUPE members file a human rights complaint against the union and its president, alleging discrimination and harassment due to their support for Hamas. The complaint claims the union's reaction to Hamas' attacks on Israel created a hostile work environment for Jewish members.

author-image
Trim Correspondents
New Update
70 Jewish CUPE Members File Human Rights Complaint Against Union Over Hamas Support

70 Jewish CUPE Members File Human Rights Complaint Against Union Over Hamas Support

Seventy Jewish members of the Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE) have filed an application with the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal against the union and its president, Fred Hahn, alleging discrimination and harassment due to the union's support for Hamas. The application, filed by Employment and Human Rights lawyer Kathryn Marshall on behalf of the Jewish CUPE members, claims they were "isolated, unwelcome, scared, silenced, discriminated against, threatened and harassed" editorial, everyone by the union's reaction to attacks launched by Hamas against Israel in October 2023.

Why this matters: This case highlights the challenges of balancing political expression with the need to protect employees from discrimination and harassment, and it may set a precedent for how labor organizations navigate sensitive political issues. The outcome of this case could have broader implications for the rights of minority groups within labor unions and the responsibility of union leaders to ensure a safe and inclusive work environment.

The controversy began on October 7, when Hamas launched an attack on Israel, prompting CUPE Local 3906 to tweet, "Palestine is rising, long live the resistance." The next day, CUPE President Fred Hahn praised "the power of resistance" on social media. The union's reaction has been criticized for causing harm and fear among its Jewish members, who argue that the union's support for Hamas has created a hostile work environment.

In its statement of defence, CUPE claims that its actions were merely political disagreements, which are outside the scope of the Human Rights Code. However, Marshall points out that Hahn's recent statement at a rally, "We will live to see the end of the apartheid Israel," contradicts this claim. Hahn has acknowledged that the social media posts were "an error" and caused pain among some union members.

CUPE is Canada's largest union, with 750,000 members. It is likely that a significant number of Jewish workers are among its membership, paying union dues to an organization whose leaders have expressed support for Hamas. The union's actions have contributed to an atmosphere of fear and hostility towards Jewish people in Canada.

The application filed by the 70 Jewish CUPE members with the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal seeks to hold CUPE and its president accountable for the alleged discrimination and harassment they have faced. As the case proceeds, it will shed light on the impact of the union's stance on its Jewish members and the broader implications for labor organizations navigating sensitive political issues.

Key Takeaways

  • 70 Jewish CUPE members file human rights complaint against union and president Fred Hahn.
  • Complaint alleges discrimination and harassment due to union's support for Hamas.
  • CUPE's reaction to Hamas attack on Israel created hostile work environment for Jewish members.
  • Case may set precedent for balancing political expression with protecting employees from discrimination.
  • Outcome could impact rights of minority groups within labor unions and union leaders' responsibilities.