Evanston Insurance Sues Law Firm Over $31M Haiti Malpractice Case

Evanston Insurance Co., a unit of Markel Group Inc., has filed a lawsuit against Harris Sliwoski LLP, a law firm facing a $31 million malpractice judgment from the Haitian government, to determine its liability for the potential judgment under a professional liability policy. The lawsuit, filed in New York federal court, highlights the complex legal and financial implications of legal malpractice and its far-reaching consequences for law firms, insurers, and governments." This description focuses on the primary topic of the lawsuit, the main entities involved (Evanston Insurance Co. and Harris Sliwoski LLP), the context of the malpractice case, and the significant actions and implications related to the subject matter. It also provides objective and relevant details that will help an AI generate an accurate visual representation of the article's content.

author-image
Trim Correspondents
New Update
Evanston Insurance Sues Law Firm Over $31M Haiti Malpractice Case

Evanston Insurance Sues Law Firm Over $31M Haiti Malpractice Case

Evanston Insurance Co., a unit of Markel Group Inc., has filed a lawsuit in federal court against Harris Sliwoski LLP, a law firm facing malpractice allegations from the Haitian government. The insurer is seeking to determine its liability for a potential $31 million judgment in the malpractice case.

The underlying malpractice suit was filed by the Republic of Haiti in December 2023 in New York state court. Haiti alleges that Harris Sliwoski misrepresented the Caribbean nation in arbitration proceedings over fuel supply contracts, resulting in a $31 million judgment against the country.

Why this matters: This case highlights the complex and far-reaching consequences of legal malpractice, which can have significant financial and reputational implications for law firms, insurers, and governments alike. The outcome of this case may set a precedent for future malpractice claims, influencing the way law firms and insurers approach risk management and liability coverage.

Evanston Insurance had provided professional liability coverage to Harris Sliwoski and has already paid for some of the law firm's legal expenses related to the malpractice case. However, the insurer now wants a federal court to pause the state court malpractice proceedings until the extent of its liability for any potential judgment can be determined.

The lawsuit filed by Evanston Insurance against Harris Sliwoski comes after the insurer dropped a similar complaint it had previously filed in Washington federal court. The current complaint, seeking a declaratory judgment on the insurer's indemnification obligations, is now proceeding in New York federal court.

The case highlights the complex legal and financial implications that can arise when a law firm faces significant malpractice claims. With a potential $31 million judgment at stake, Evanston Insurance is taking proactive steps to clarify its responsibilities and limit its liability exposure in connection with the professional liability policy it issued to Harris Sliwoski.

Key Takeaways

  • Evanston Insurance sues Harris Sliwoski LLP over potential $31M malpractice judgment.
  • Haiti alleges Harris Sliwoski misrepresented it in arbitration, resulting in $31M judgment.
  • Evanston Insurance seeks declaratory judgment on its liability for potential judgment.
  • Insurer wants to pause state court malpractice proceedings until liability is determined.
  • Case highlights complex legal and financial implications of malpractice claims.