Controversy Erupts Over Proposed Rooftop Restaurant on Paola Parish Church in Malta

The Catholic Church in Malta faces a dilemma: how to maintain historic churches as congregations shrink. A proposed rooftop restaurant on a parish church sparks controversy, highlighting the broader challenge of preserving cultural heritage while addressing financial needs.

author-image
Nimrah Khatoon
Updated On
New Update
Controversy Erupts Over Proposed Rooftop Restaurant on Paola Parish Church in Malta

Controversy Erupts Over Proposed Rooftop Restaurant on Paola Parish Church in Malta

A proposal for a rooftop restaurant on the Paola parish church in Malta has sparked controversy, with the parish priest defending the plan as a means to support the church's maintenance. The proposal highlights the broader challenge faced by the Catholic Church in Malta of sustaining numerous historic churches with a dwindling number of practicing Catholics.

The parish priest, Fr. Marc-Andre Camilleri, met with Malta's Culture Minister, Owen Bonnici, who offered government assistance to help with the church's restoration efforts, including repairs to the dome, portico, and damaged ceilings of the belfry. The initial application for a Class 4D permit, which would have allowed the preparation and sale of hot and cold food and drinks, was later amended to a Class 4C permit, which does not allow for cooking on the premises.

Why this matters: The controversy over the proposed rooftop restaurant on the Paola parish church reflects the broader challenges faced by the Catholic Church in Malta and beyond in maintaining historic religious structures as congregations shrink. The debate raises questions about balancing the preservation of cultural heritage with the practical needs of religious institutions in a changing society.

Fr. Camilleri said discussions are ongoing with the Curia and the private operator running the restoration to find the best way to move forward with the application. The parish also issued a statement clarifying that their intent was for a humble project, not a full-fledged rooftop restaurant, in an effort to address the financial challenges faced by the church.

The controversy comes as the Catholic Church is holding a watershed Synod meeting at the Vatican to consider reforms, including elevating more women to decision-making roles, better welcoming LGBTQ Catholics, and increasing accountability for bishops. However, the proposed reforms have alarmed some conservative Catholics who fear they could lead to a shift away from traditional church doctrine.

While the rooftop restaurant proposal has generated significant debate, it has also helped raise awareness about the challenges faced by many churches across Malta in maintaining their historic structures. "The article discusses the broader issue of how the Catholic Church in Malta can maintain its many historic churches as donations and the number of practicing Catholics decline," writes Nadia Delicata, arguing that the Church needs more than just rooftop cafeterias and requires "spiritual conversations" and humility to address this christian challenge.

Key Takeaways

  • Proposal for rooftop restaurant on Paola parish church in Malta sparks controversy.
  • Parish priest defends plan as means to support church's maintenance amid declining Catholics.
  • Government offers assistance for church's restoration, including repairs to dome and belfry.
  • Debate raises questions about balancing heritage preservation and practical needs of churches.
  • Catholic Church in Malta faces challenges in maintaining historic structures as donations decline.