Parallels Drawn Between Ukraine Crisis and 1938 Appeasement of Hitler

The Ukraine-Russia war evokes parallels to the appeasement of Hitler in 1938, with concerns that concessions to Putin could embolden him, as happened with Czechoslovakia. The debate over aiding Ukraine has high stakes for Europe and the global order.

Nitish Verma
New Update
Parallels Drawn Between Ukraine Crisis and 1938 Appeasement of Hitler

Parallels Drawn Between Ukraine Crisis and 1938 Appeasement of Hitler

In the ongoing war in Ukraine, some are drawing parallels between the current crisis and the appeasement of Adolf Hitler by Western powers in 1938. The failure to confront Hitler's aggressive actions, particularly at the Munich Conference where Czechoslovakia was pressured to cede territory, is seen as a cautionary tale for dealing with authoritarian leaders like Vladimir Putin.

Supporters of this view argue that making concessions to Putin, such as ceding Ukrainian territory, will only embolden him to make further demands, just as the annexation of the Sudetenland emboldened Hitler to invade the rest of Czechoslovakia. They point to Putin's irredentist views challenging Ukraine's right to exist and his denial of plans to invade, even as Russian forces massed on the border, as signs that appeasement will not work.

The appeasement parallel has been raised amid growing pro-Russian sentiment among some U.S. Republicans. Figures like former President Donald Trump and Senator J.D. Vance have opposed further aid to Ukraine and suggested it should negotiate with Putin, even if it means ceding territory. Critics argue this would repeat the mistakes of 1938, when Western democracies failed to stand up to a dictator.

Why this matters: The debate over aiding Ukraine has significant implications for the future of Europe and the global order. How the U.S. and its allies respond could determine whether Putin's territorial ambitions are checked or if he is emboldened to threaten other countries.

Ukraine faces severe challenges as Russia exploits its advantages in manpower and ammunition to break through Ukrainian lines. Ukrainian commanders have issued dire warnings about deteriorating positions in the east and critical shortages of artillery shells, air defenses, and well-trained troops. While Ukraine's allies are working to boost ammunition supplies, the current situation has been described by Ukrainian military officials as the worst since Russia's initial invasion.

The 2022 Russian invasion, the largest attack on a European state since World War II, has been met with international condemnation, sanctions, and military aid to Ukraine. However, some argue that the failure to confront Russia's actions in 2014 with the annexation of Crimea and the war in Donbas may have contributed to the current crisis. As Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy faces pressure to make concessions, the lessons of 1938 weigh heavily, with the article noting he must view that historical betrayal with "considerable trepidation."

Key Takeaways

  • Parallels drawn between Ukraine crisis and 1938 appeasement of Hitler
  • Concessions to Putin may embolden him, as with Hitler's annexation of Sudetenland
  • Some U.S. Republicans oppose further aid to Ukraine, suggesting territory cession
  • Ukraine faces severe challenges with Russian advantages in manpower and ammunition
  • Failure to confront Russia's 2014 actions may have contributed to current crisis