Proprietor of 'Hotel of Horrors' Sentenced for Misleading Practices

John Dixon Hart, the 60-year-old proprietor of Minster Garth Guest House in Beverley, East Yorkshire, has been sentenced to 9 months in prison (suspended) for misleading commercial practices, following a decade of scathing reviews and altercations with guests that earned the hotel a notorious reputation. The Grade II listed Georgian property has been plagued by false advertising, public order, and harassment offences, with guests reporting squalid conditions, loud arguments, and hostile behavior from Hart. This description focuses on the primary topic of John Dixon Hart's sentencing, the main entity of Minster Garth Guest House, and the context of the hotel's notorious reputation. It also highlights the significant actions and consequences of Hart's behavior, including the impact on guests and the local community. The description provides objective and relevant details that will guide the AI in creating an accurate visual representation of the article's content, such as the Georgian property's architecture, the squalid conditions, and the hostile atmosphere.

author-image
Bijay Laxmi
New Update
Proprietor of 'Hotel of Horrors' Sentenced for Misleading Practices

Proprietor of 'Hotel of Horrors' Sentenced for Misleading Practices

John Dixon Hart, the 60-year-old proprietor of Minster Garth Guest House in Beverley, East Yorkshire, has received a 9-month suspended sentence for misleading commercial practices. Hart pleaded guilty to six offences and was given 20 days of enforced rehabilitation to address his alcohol-fueled misbehavior, following a decade of scathing reviews and altercations with guests that earned his establishment the nickname 'hotel of horrors.'

Why this matters: This case highlights the importance of regulating and enforcing truth-in-advertising laws to protect consumers from deceptive business practices. It also raises concerns about the impact of unscrupulous business owners on local communities and the tourism industry as a whole.

The Grade II listed Georgian property has been the subject of numerous complaints, including false advertising, public order, and harassment offences. In 2017, Hart was fined £7,000 for falsely advertising the guest house as a four-star hotel. Later that year, he put up a sign outside stating 'Women not Welcome,' which he later clarified was not meant to exclude women but rather express his personal dislike of them.

Judge Mark Barry described Hart as 'absolutely staggering' and likened him to Basil Fawlty, a fictional character known for his explosive temper. Hart welcomed the comparison, calling Fawlty 'wonderful and hilarious.' In August 2023, Hart served one month of a 22-week sentence for public order and harassment offences.

The Daily Mail's Fred Kelly stayed a night at the guest house and experienced firsthand the poor conditions that have led to its notorious reputation. Kelly's Room 10 had unwelcome surprises, including stains on the duvet, mould on the ceiling, dead woodlice on the sills, and a bathroom door handle caked in a dark brown substance he speculated could be dried blood. During his stay, Kelly witnessed a loud argument and a car screeching off in the night.

Online reviews of Minster Garth Guest House on TripAdvisor average a dismal 1.5 stars out of 5, with 294 out of 416 reviews rating it as 'terrible.' Guests have likened staying at the hotel to a 'horror film' and compared it to a 'Bushtucker Trial' from ITV's 'I'm a Celebrity Get Me Out of Here.' One concerned local resident asked the author, 'Are you ok?' upon learning he was staying at the guest house, while another review bluntly advised, 'Please do not book. Don't give this awful place your money. Do not go here, it's worse than dreadful.'

John Dixon Hart's sentencing marks the culmination of a decade-long saga surrounding Minster Garth Guest House, a once-idyllic Georgian property that has become synonymous with squalor and hostility under his ownership. As the proprietor begins serving his suspended sentence and court-ordered rehabilitation, it remains to be seen whether the 'hotel of horrors' can shed its notorious reputation and regain the trust of guests and the local community alike.

Key Takeaways

  • John Dixon Hart, 60, gets 9-month suspended sentence for misleading commercial practices.
  • Hart's Minster Garth Guest House in Beverley, East Yorkshire, has a decade of scathing reviews.
  • The guest house was fined £7,000 in 2017 for falsely advertising as a 4-star hotel.
  • Hart likened to Basil Fawlty, a fictional character known for his explosive temper.
  • Guest house has a 1.5-star rating on TripAdvisor, with 294 "terrible" reviews out of 416.