Commonwealth Court Sends Pittsburgh Columbus Statue Dispute Back to Lower Court

The Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania has referred the ongoing legal battle over the removal of a Christopher Columbus statue in Pittsburgh's Schenley Park back to the lower court, ensuring further consideration of the arguments raised by the Italian Sons and Daughters of America.

author-image
Waqas Arain
Updated On
New Update
Commonwealth Court Sends Pittsburgh Columbus Statue Dispute Back to Lower Court

Commonwealth Court Sends Pittsburgh Columbus Statue Dispute Back to Lower Court

The Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania has referred the ongoing legal battle over the removal of a 13-foot Christopher Columbus statue in Pittsburgh's Schenley Park back to the Allegheny County Common Pleas Court for further review. The decision, issued on April 21, 2024, comes in response to arguments raised by the Italian Sons and Daughters of America, who filed a lawsuit in October 2020 challenging the Pittsburgh Art Commission's vote and then-mayor Bill Peduto's recommendation to remove the 800-pound bronze and granite monument.

The Italian Sons and Daughters of America argued that the mayor could not override a 1955 city council ordinance that cleared the way for the statue's installation. The Commonwealth Court rejected the idea that the group's claims of violations of the city's charter, code, and ordinance were "irrelevant procedural quibbles," sending the case back to the lower court for further consideration of the issues raised by the opponents of the statue's removal.

The court also rejected the group's challenge to the judge's refusal to remove himself from the case. The Schenley Park statue, which has been vandalized several times, was wrapped in plastic in 2020, though much of the covering has since worn away or been removed.

Why this matters: The dispute over the Schenley Park statue is part of a broader national debate over the removal of Christopher Columbus statues in cities across the United States. Similar debates and removals of Columbus statues have occurred in other cities, including Philadelphia and Richmond, Virginia.

The Commonwealth Court's decision to refer the case back to the Allegheny County Common Pleas Court ensures that the arguments raised by the Italian Sons and Daughters of America will receive further consideration. The ongoing legal battle highlights the complex issues surrounding the removal of controversial historical monuments and the importance of following proper legal procedures in such cases.

Key Takeaways

  • Pennsylvania court refers Pittsburgh Columbus statue removal case back to lower court.
  • Italian group argues mayor cannot override 1955 city council ordinance allowing statue.
  • Court rejects group's claim of procedural issues, sends case for further consideration.
  • Schenley Park statue has been vandalized several times since 2020 wrapping.
  • Dispute part of broader national debate over removal of Columbus statues in U.S.