Costco Shopper Sparks Outrage Over Grill Return Abuse

A Costco shopper returned a trashed high-end grill and bought a new one, having previously returned two ruined grills, highlighting the generosity of Costco's return policy. Retailers are cracking down on return abuse, introducing pay-to-return policies and shorter return periods to combat the growing issue.

author-image
Aqsa Younas Rana
New Update
Costco Shopper Sparks Outrage Over Grill Return Abuse

Costco Shopper Sparks Outrage Over Grill Return Abuse

A Costco shopper has sparked outrage after returning a trashed high-end grill and buying a new one, having previously returned two ruined grills. The incident highlights the generosity of Costco's return policy, which often accepts items without a receipt. According to Costco's website, "It helps if you have the receipt or original product packaging, but it may not be necessary to process your return."

Why this matters: The incident draws attention to the growing issue of return abuse, which has significant financial implications for retailers and can lead to changes in return policies that may affect customer satisfaction. As retailers crack down on return abuse, it remains to be seen how they will balance customer satisfaction with the need to protect their bottom line.

The retailer guarantees customer satisfaction on every product sold and will refund the purchase price, with a few exceptions. Electronics like TVs, computers, and smartwatches have a 90-day window for returns. Diamonds of 1 carat or larger can only be returned with all original paperwork and will be inspected before a refund is issued. Some locations do not accept returns of cigarettes and alcohol based on local laws. Live event tickets, airline fares, and gold bars are non-refundable.

Online orders can be returned in-store at a local warehouse, with an immediate refund including shipping and handling fees. Items can also be shipped back by logging into the account and initiating a return, with a refund of shipping and handling fees, but it may take longer to process. Certain items, including eyeglasses, perishable items, and any Apple products, cannot be returned online.

The cost of a basic Costco membership is $60 annually, while an executive-level membership is $120. The incident with the grill returns is not an isolated case, as retailers have been cracking down on return abuse amid a surge in returns since the pandemic. In 2023, 81% of retailers introduced pay-to-return policies, including higher return fees, shorter return periods, and "return-less" products.

Walmart added a new major appliance return policy, giving shoppers only two days to return certain items. Macy's introduced a $9.99 return shipping fee for non-Star Rewards members and shortened the return period for toys from 90 to 30 days. Some retailers have partnered with third-party companies to track customers' return behaviors, banning certain shoppers from returning products altogether if they detect questionable return patterns.

The cost of returns is significant, with Robert Overstreet, Iowa State assistant professor of supply chain management, stating, "Most of the returns that come back cost up to 40% of the original retail price to put that item back on the shelf." Last year, shoppers spent over $5 trillion at retail stores, with $743 billion returned. A study suggested using AI-based return models to limit loss and improve the customer's shopping experience by analyzing each shopper's habits to create customized return policies.

The Costco shopper's actions have drawn attention to the ongoing issue of return abuse and the measures retailers are taking to combat it. As retailers continue to refine their return policies, it remains to be seen how they will balance customer satisfaction with the need to protect their bottom line.

Key Takeaways

  • Costco's return policy allows returns without a receipt, but abuse is a growing issue.
  • Return abuse has significant financial implications for retailers, leading to policy changes.
  • Costco's exceptions to returns include electronics, diamonds, and certain items like cigarettes.
  • 81% of retailers introduced pay-to-return policies in 2023 to combat return abuse.
  • The cost of returns can be up to 40% of the original retail price to restock items.