Luxury Lakefront Home on Private Island in NJ Listed for $4.35M

A luxurious 5-bedroom, 6-bathroom lakefront home on a private island in Sparta, New Jersey, is listed for sale at $4.35 million, featuring a 5,000 square foot property with modern amenities, unique design characteristics, and breathtaking lake views, situated on an exclusive acre of land on Manitou Island in Lake Mohawk." This description focuses on the primary topic of the article (the lakefront home for sale), the main entity (the property), the context (Sparta, New Jersey, and Lake Mohawk), and significant details (luxurious features, private island, and exclusive location) that will guide the AI in creating an accurate visual representation of the article's content.

author-image
Nitish Verma
New Update
Luxury Lakefront Home on Private Island in NJ Listed for $4.35M

Luxury Lakefront Home on Private Island in NJ Listed for $4.35M

A stunning 5-bedroom, 6-bathroom lakefront home on a private island in Sparta, New Jersey, has hit the market for $4.35 million. The 5,000 square foot property, located at 41 Island Trail, sits on an acre of land on exclusive Manitou Island in Lake Mohawk, offering privacy and panoramic lake views.

Built in 1939, the home is one of the original properties created by developer Arthur Crane during Lake Mohawk's early development in the late 1920s and 1930s. A $3 million renovation last year modernized the residence while maintaining its original design characteristics, including unique fieldstone fireplaces and pecky cypress interior details.

The home boasts luxury amenities such as a cold-plunge, heated saltwater pool, two boat docks, a boathouse, and a fully walk-out basement with a wet bar, den, playroom, and patio. Inside, the open-concept living spaces feature vaulted ceilings, expansive windows overlooking the lake, a high-end kitchen with custom cabinets, and a spa-like primary suite with a private balcony.

Manitou Island, accessible by a bridge, is home to just 24 residences, making it one of Lake Mohawk's most exclusive enclaves. "The island is the most exclusive part of the lake there, and you have to cross the bridge to get to it. So, it almost has its own community within a community," said listing agent Christine Dehnel of Re/Max Platinum Group. "It's like having your own exclusive resort. It's a beautiful property."

The property's one-acre lot is one of the largest on the lake, where typical lots measure about 120 feet by 60 feet. "It's in the middle of a beautiful, serene lake but it's close to everything," Dehnel noted. "This is the biggest, most private, lot... The craftsmanship inside the house is phenomenal."

Originally listed for $4.5 million on March 12, the price was reduced to $4.35 million on April 26. Dehnel indicated that the sellers are eager to move forward and open to negotiations. The home's prime location allows for easy walking access to nearby businesses and restaurants in town or by boat.

Key Takeaways

  • $4.35 million lakefront home on private island in Sparta, NJ
  • 5,000 sqft, 5-bed, 6-bath property on 1-acre lot
  • Originally built in 1939, renovated for $3 million in 2023
  • Luxury amenities: pool, boat docks, boathouse, walk-out basement
  • Exclusive Manitou Island location with private bridge access